This page contains documents related to the Portland Water Bureaus’s project to build a drinking water filtration facility and pipelines.
Contents:
Hearing Documents
Transportation Permits
Application Materials
Hearing Documents
- T3-2022-16220 Hearings Officer's Decision (2.41 MB)
- Video of Hearing on Portland Water Bureau's Land Use Application (video, 4:59:05)
- T3-2022-16220 Staff Report (1.51 MB)
- Post Hearing Memo to Hearings Officer rec 8.7.23 (268.09 KB)
- Portland Water Bureau Exhibit List - (current to 9.28.23) (337.05 KB)
Transportation Permits
Application Materials
All documents shown are part of the land use record. Where a document has been replaced by a newer submittal, a note labeling it as revised has been placed after the link with direction to the replacing document.
If these documents do not open directly in your browser, you may still download them in order to view.
Exhibits:
A. Applicant's Submitted Documents
B. Staff Exhibits
C. Procedural Exhibits
D. Public Comments
E. Exhibits Submitted Post Staff Report Issuance
H. Hearing Exhibits
I. Post Hearing Exhibits - New Evidence Period
J. Post Hearing Exhibits - Rebuttal Period
K. Post Rebuttal Period
L. Final Argument Period
Applicant's Submitted Documents
- Exhibit A.1 PWB Permit Application Forms (1.73 MB)
- Exhibit A.2 Land Use Applications Introduction (18.06 MB)
- Exhibit A.3 1. Filtration Facility Site Overview (12.44 MB)
- Exhibit A.4 1.A Filtration Facility Conditional Use Application Narrative (63.34 MB)
- Exhibit A.5 1.B Filtration Facility Design Review Application Narrative (26.29 MB)
- Exhibit A.6 1.C Communications Tower Conditional Use and Design Review Application Narrative (15.84 MB)[Revised, see 4.18.23 1.C Communications Tower Conditional Use and Design Review Application Narrative_April 2023]
- Exhibit A.7 2. Pipeline Overview (21.28 MB)
- Exhibit A.8 2.A Pipelines Conditional Use Application Narrative (17.22 MB)
- Exhibit A.9 2.B Pipelines Design Review Application Narrative (10.9 MB)
- Exhibit A.10 2.C Pipeline EFU Review Application Narrative (5.15 MB)
- Exhibit A.11 2.D Pipeline SEC Review Application Narrative (17.79 MB)
- Exhibit A.12 A.1a Flysheet (14.83 KB)
- Exhibit A.13 A.1a Site Plans (32.87 MB)[Revised, see 3.20.23 Appendix A.1a]
- Exhibit A.14 A.1b Flysheet (15.3 KB)
- Exhibit A.15 A.1b Architectural Plans (20.57 MB)
- Exhibit A.16 A.1c Flysheet (17.18 KB)
- Exhibit A.17 A.1c Civil Engineering Plans (7.12 MB)
- Exhibit A.18 A.2a Flysheet (14.92 KB)
- Exhibit A.19 A.2a Pipeline Site Plans (16.99 MB)[Revised, see 3.24.23 Appendix A.2a]
- Exhibit A.20 A.2b Flysheet (16.54 KB)
- Exhibit A.21 A.2b Architectural Plans (3.08 MB)
- Exhibit A.22 A.2c Flysheet (15.76 KB)
- Exhibit A.23 A.2c Pipeline and Civil Engineering Drawings (3.5 MB)
- Exhibit A.24 A.3 Flysheet (16.97 KB)
- Exhibit A.25 A.3 Significant Environment Concern Overlay Drawings (4.68 MB)
- Exhibit A.26 B.1 Flysheet (16.79 KB)
- Exhibit A.27 B.1 Bull Run Treatment Projects Outreach History. (5.22 MB)
- Exhibit A.28 B.2 Flysheet (17.18 KB)
- Exhibit A.29 B.2 Bull Run Filtration Site Advisory Group Summary (11.67 MB)
- Exhibit A.30 C.1 Flysheet (17.27 KB)
- Exhibit A.31 C.1 Bull Run Filtration Project Traffic Impact Analysis (54.82 MB)
- Exhibit A.32 D.1 Flysheet (18.18 KB)
- Exhibit A.33 D.1 Agricultural Compatibility Study (78.85 MB)
- Exhibit A.34 D.2 Flysheet (16.63 KB)
- Exhibit A.35 D.2 Agricultural Soil Restoration Study (9.79 MB)
- Exhibit A.36 D.3 Flysheet (16.4 KB)
- Exhibit A.37 D.3 Forestry Compatibility Study (7.14 MB)
- Exhibit A.38 D.4 Flysheet (16.42 KB)
- Exhibit A.39 D.4 Pesticides Report (21.26 MB)
- Exhibit A.40 D.5 Flysheet (20.46 KB)
- Exhibit A.41 D.5 Potential Impacts of Pesticide Use on Finished Water Quality (19.16 MB)
- Exhibit A.42 D.6 Flysheet (18.09 KB)
- Exhibit A.43 D.6 Lusted Hill Treatment Facility Recorded Farm and Forest Deed Restriction (345.8 KB)
- Exhibit A.44 E.1 Flysheet (17.83 KB)
- Exhibit A.45 E.1 Oregon Water Treatment Plant Operations (9.69 MB)
- Exhibit A.46 E.2 Flysheet (15.08 KB)
- Exhibit A.47 E.2 Land Use Permitting Lighting Report (15.06 MB)
- Exhibit A.48 E.3 Flysheet (17.07 KB)
- Exhibit A.49 E.3 Bull Run Filtration Facility Exterior Noise Analysis (8.02 MB)
- Exhibit A.50 E.4 Flysheet (16.27 KB)
- Exhibit A.51 E.4 Potential Local Impacts of Facility Operation (2.41 MB)
- Exhibit A.52 E.5 Flysheet (16.02 KB)
- Exhibit A.53 E.5 Filtration Facility Odor Considerations (6.98 MB)
- Exhibit A.54 E.6 Flysheet (16.28 KB)
- Exhibit A.55 E.6 Hazardous Materials Management Plan (9.85 MB)
- Exhibit A.56 E.7 Flysheet (16.56 KB)
- Exhibit A.57 E.7 Potential Discharges to Johnson Creek (2.19 MB)
- Exhibit A.58 E.8a Flysheet (18.04 KB)
- Exhibit A.59 E.8a Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife Communication (444.09 KB)
- Exhibit A.60 E.8b Flysheet (18.71 KB)
- Exhibit A.61 E.8b Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife Deer & Elk Habitat Map (213.52 KB)
- Exhibit A.62 F.1 Flysheet (17.54 KB)
- Exhibit A.63 F.1 Exterior Site Lighting Analysis Finish Water Intertie Facility (5.04 MB)
- Exhibit A.64 F.2 Flysheet (18.47 KB)
- Exhibit A.65 F.2 Preliminary Acoustical Analysis of the Facility Pipeline Finished Water Intertie (6.71 MB)
- Exhibit A.66 G.1 Flysheet (16.64 KB)
- Exhibit A.67 G.1 Raw Water Pipeline Wildlife Conservation Plan (3.94 MB)
- Exhibit A.68 G.2 Flysheet (16.45 KB)
- Exhibit A.69 G.2 Distribution Main Wildlife Conservation Plan (3.37 MB)
- Exhibit A.70 G.3 Flysheet (17.45 KB)
- Exhibit A.71 G.3 Draft Inadvertent Discovery Plan for Cultural Resources (992.43 KB)
- Exhibit A.72 H.1 Flysheet (16.89 KB)
- Exhibit A.73 H.1 Filtration Facility Stormwater Drainage Report (110.22 MB)
- Exhibit A.74 H.2 Flysheet (17.8 KB)
- Exhibit A.75 H.2 Finished Water Intertie Stormwater Report (22.25 MB)
- Exhibit A.76 H.3 Flysheet (17.4 KB)
- Exhibit A.77 H.3 Pipelines Stormwater Report (32.57 MB)
- Exhibit A.78 H.4 Flysheet (18.03 KB)
- Exhibit A.79 H.4 Stormwater Drainage Control Certification – Bull Run Filtration Facility. (1.97 MB)[Revised, see 1.27.23 Attachment J.2]
- Exhibit A.80 I.1 Flysheet (18.7 KB)
- Exhibit A.81 I.1a Filtration Facility Geotechnical Engineering Summary (555.31 KB)
- Exhibit A.82 I.1b Raw Water Pipelines Geotechnical Engineering Summary (464.54 KB)
- Exhibit A.83 1.1c Finished Water Pipelines Geotechnical Engineering Summary (666.46 KB)
- Exhibit A.84 I.2 Flysheet (17.8 KB)
- Exhibit A.85 I.2 Raw Water Pipeline Alternatives from Lusted Road to Filtration Facility (1.24 MB)
- Exhibit A.86 I.3 Flysheet (17.16 KB)
- Exhibit A.87 I.3 Raw Water Pipelines Geologic Hazards Permit Form (13.5 MB)
- Exhibit A.88 I.4 Flysheet (18.14 KB)
- Exhibit A.89 I.4 Lusted Road Distribution Main Geologic Hazards Permit Form (10.54 MB)
- Exhibit A.90 J.1 Flysheet (16.9 KB)
- Exhibit A.91 J.1 Gravel Road Emergency Vehicle Support (575.34 KB)
- Exhibit A.92 K.2 Flysheet (16.68 KB)
- Exhibit A.93 K.2 Current Title Reports (30.29 MB)
- Exhibit A.94 K.3a Filtration Facility Property Deeds (5 MB)
- Exhibit A.95 K.3b Flysheet (17.89 KB)
- Exhibit A.96 K.3b Finished Water Pipelines Property Deeds (37.61 MB)
- Exhibit A.97 K.3c Flysheet (17.81 KB)
- Exhibit A.98 K.3c Raw Water Pipelines Property Deeds (11.33 MB)
- Exhibit A.99 K.4a Flysheet (16.09 KB)
- Exhibit A.100 K.4a Historic Imagery Filtration Facility (949.58 KB)
- Exhibit A.101 K.4b Flysheet (16.73 KB)
- Exhibit A.102 K.4b Historic Imagery Raw Water Pipelines (626.92 KB)
- Exhibit A.103 K.5 Flysheet (14.85 KB)
- Exhibit A.104 K.5 Partition Plats – Partition Plat 1991-111 (5.65 MB)
- Exhibit A.105 K.6 Flysheet (18.06 KB)
- Exhibit A.106 K.6 Historic Zoning Maps 1S4E23C-1400 and 1500 (4.76 MB)
- Exhibit A.107 L.1 Flysheet (17.21 KB)
- Exhibit A.108 L.1 Multnomah County Sheriff's Office Facility Will Serve Form (498.94 KB)
- Exhibit A.109 L.2 Flysheet (17.15 KB)
- Exhibit A.110 L.2 Multnomah County Sheriff's Office Intertie Will Serve Form (485.28 KB)
- Exhibit A.111 L.3 Flysheet (17.36 KB)
- Exhibit A.112 L.3 Clackamas County Sheriff's Office Will Serve Letter (251.57 KB)
- Exhibit A.113 L.4 Flysheet (15.9 KB)
- Exhibit A.114 L.4 Sandy Fire District 72 Will Serve Letter (204.05 KB)
- Exhibit A.115 L.5a Flysheet (16.44 KB)
- Exhibit A.116 L.5a Portland General Electric Facility Will Serve Letter (444.03 KB)
- Exhibit A.117 L.5b Flysheet (16.37 KB)
- Exhibit A.118 L.5b Portland General Electric Intertie Will Serve Letter (292.31 KB)
- Exhibit A.119 L.6 Flysheet (16.83 KB)
- Exhibit A.120 L.6 M.V.S. & Recycling Services Will Serve Letter (455.03 KB)
- Exhibit A.121 L.7 Flysheet (14.96 KB)
- Exhibit A.122 L.7 Ziply Fiber Will Serve Letter (804.28 KB)
- Exhibit A.123 L.8 Flysheet (16.17 KB)
- Exhibit A.124 L.8 Septic Review Certification (26.45 MB)
- Exhibit A.125 L.9 Flysheet (15.67 KB)
- Exhibit A.126 L.9a Portland Water Bureau Facility Will Serve Letter (647.77 KB)
- Exhibit A.127 L.9b Pleasant Home Water District Intertie Certification of Water Service (205.88 KB)
- Exhibit A.128 L.9c Pleasant Home Water District Certification of Water Service (1.31 MB)
- Exhibit A.129 L.10 Flysheet (17.13 KB)
- Exhibit A.130 L.10 Fire Service Agency Review (4.21 MB)
- Exhibit A.131 M.1 Flysheet (15.43 KB)
- Exhibit A.132 M.1 Design Report (3.65 MB)
- Exhibit A.133 M.2 Flysheet (15.89 KB)
- Exhibit A.134 M.2 Bull Run Tower Design Drawing (760.07 KB)[Revised, see 1.27.23 Attachment D.2]
- Exhibit A.135 M.3 Flysheet (16.3 KB)
- Exhibit A.136 M.3 Bull Run Tower Foundation Design (913.88 KB)
- Exhibit A.137 M.4 Flysheet (16.58 KB)
- Exhibit A.138 M.4 Communication Tower Design Calculations (10.05 MB)
- Exhibit A.139 M.5 Flysheet (17.96 KB)
- Exhibit A.140 M.5 Design Criteria and Failure Modes for Valmont Communication Towers (1.19 MB)
- Exhibit A.141 M.6 Flysheet (17.89 KB)
- Exhibit A.142 M.6 Federal Aviation Administration Determination of No Hazard to Air Navigation (443.03 KB)
- Exhibit A.143 M.7 Flysheet (19.51 KB)
- Exhibit A.144 M.7 Oregon Department of Aviation Comments Regarding Construction or Alteration of an Antenna Tower (884.12 KB)
- Exhibit A.145 M.8 Flysheet (17.46 KB)
- Exhibit A.146 M.8 Federal Communications Commission Radio Station Authorization (215.51 KB)
- Exhibit A.147 M.9a Flysheet (16.75 KB)
- Exhibit A.148 M.9a Microwave Path Survey Interpretation Memo (886.36 KB)
- Exhibit A.149 M.9b Flysheet (16.55 KB)
- Exhibit A.150 M.9b Microwave Path Survey Report (6.31 MB)
- Exhibit A.151 M.10 Flysheet (18.99 KB)
- Exhibit A.152 M.10 Proposed Tower for Bull Run Filtration Facility Ice Hazards and Mitigation Measures (801.03 KB)
- Exhibit A.153 M.11 Flysheet (16.81 KB)
- Exhibit A.154 M.11 Proposed Bull Run Filtration Tower NIER Study (4.21 MB)
- Exhibit A.155 N.1 Resumes (24.94 MB)
- Exhibit A.156 O.1 Flysheet (17.15 KB)
- Exhibit A.157 O.1 Study Area Images (24.36 MB)
- Exhibit A.158 O.2 Flysheet (16.29 KB)
- Exhibit A.159 O.2a 2022-15566 Pre-Application Conference Notes (3.56 MB)
- Exhibit A.160 O.2b 2022-15566 PWB Bull Run Filtration Project Transportation Comments (2.21 MB)
- Exhibit A.161 O.3 Flysheet (17.35 KB)
- Exhibit A.162 O.3 Prior Land Use Decisions (64.44 MB)
- Exhibit A.163 Bull Run Filtration Land Use Completeness Response Narrative (342.91 KB)
- Exhibit A.164 Attachment E.1 Geologic Hazards Permits Narrative (1.76 MB)
- Exhibit A.165 Attachment K.1a Cathodic Protection Rectifiers Narrative (3.53 MB)[Revised]
- Exhibit A.166 Attachment A.1a Legal Lot Deed (3.58 MB)
- Exhibit A.167 Attachment A.1b Legal Lot Map (124.82 KB)
- Exhibit A.168 Attachment A.2a Contract 1971 (2.01 MB)
- Exhibit A.169 Attachment A.2b Contract Assignment 1975 (1.44 MB)
- Exhibit A.170 Attachment B.1 Resume Adam Jenkins PE INCE (188.53 KB)
- Exhibit A.171 Attachment B.1 Resume Justin Morgan INCE (172.28 KB)
- Exhibit A.172 Attachment B.1 Acoustic Baseline Measurement (4.38 MB)
- Exhibit A.173 B.1 Flysheet (16.06 KB)
- Exhibit A.174 C.1 Flysheet (17.42 KB)
- Exhibit A.175 Attachment C.1 Pre-Construction Ambient Sound Level Measurement (6.34 MB)
- Exhibit A.176 Attachment D.1 Antennae Data Sheets (3.1 MB)
- Exhibit A.177 Attachment D.2 Tower Drawing with Antennae (670.84 KB)
- Exhibit A.178 Attachment D.3 Tower Antennae Locations (297.37 KB)
- Exhibit A.179 E.2 Flysheet (18.12 KB)
- Exhibit A.180 Attachment E.2 Responses to County Comments on Geologic Hazards Permits (21.97 MB)
- Exhibit A.181 F.1 Flysheet (18.07 KB)
- Exhibit A.182 Attachment F.1 Landscape Drawing Sheets (17.18 MB)
- Exhibit A.183 Attachment G.2 Ancillary Building Drawing Sheets (1.28 MB)
- Exhibit A.184 Attachment G.3 Tower Area Drawing Sheet (5.47 MB)[Revised, see 3.20.23 Appendix A.1a]
- Exhibit A.185 Attachment H.1 Appurtenances and Grading Drawing Sheets (1.69 MB)[Also in 3.24.23 Appendix A.2a]
- Exhibit A.186 Attachment H.2a Intertie Yard Setbacks (49.41 KB)
- Exhibit A.187 Attachment H.2b Intertie Site Plan Drawing Sheet (2.63 MB)[Revised, see 3.24.23 Appendix A.2a]
- Exhibit A.188 Attachment H.2c Intertie Landscape Drawing Sheet (4.59 MB)[Revised see 3.24.23 Appendix A.2a]
- Exhibit A.189 Attachment H.2d Intertie Model View Lusted Road (321.45 KB)[Revised, see 3.24.23 Appendix A.2a]
- Exhibit A.190 Attachment H.2e Intertie Model View Lusted Road (370.7 KB)[Revised, see 3.24.23 Appendix A.2a]
- Exhibit A.191 Attachment H.2f Intertie Model View Lusted Road (399.41 KB)[Revised, see 3.24.23 Appendix A.2a]
- Exhibit A.192 Attachment H.2g Intertie Model View Farm Road (812.26 KB)[Revised, see 3.24.23 Appendix A.2a]
- Exhibit A.193 I.1 Flysheet (17.79 KB)
- Exhibit A.194 Attachment I.1 Pipeline SEC Drawing Sheets (4.58 MB)
- Exhibit A.195 Attachment I.2 Multnomah Connection Proposed Ground Disturbance (621.59 KB)
- Exhibit A.196 J.2 Flysheet (17.37 KB)
- Exhibit A.197 Attachment J.2a Stormwater Drainage Control Certificate Facility (1.31 MB)
- Exhibit A.198 Attachment J.2b Stormwater Drainage Control Certificate Intertie (850.75 KB)
- Exhibit A.199 Attachment J.2c Stormwater Drainage Control Certificate Pipelines (915.4 KB)
- Exhibit A.200 Attachment J.6 Existing Retaining Wall. (2.95 MB)
- Exhibit A.201 Attachment J.7a Pipeline Drawing Sheets Site Plans (20.91 MB)[Revised, see 3.24.23 Appendix A.2a]
- Exhibit A.202 Attachment J.7b Pipeline Drawing Sheets Architectural Plans (3.1 MB)
- Exhibit A.203 Attachment J.7c Pipeline Drawing Sheets Civil Plans (5.44 MB)
- Exhibit A.204 Attachment K.1b Agricultural Review of Cathodic Protection Rectifiers (561.55 KB)
- Exhibit A.205 K.3a Flysheet (18.65 KB)
- Exhibit A.206 Attachment K.3a Off-site Improvements Drawing Sheets (5.34 MB)
- Exhibit A.207 Attachment K.3b Off-site Grading and Paving Drawing Sheets (5 MB)
- Exhibit A.208 Attachment K.3c Off-site Roadway Plan and Profile Drawing Sheets (4.83 MB)
- Exhibit A.209 Revised Attachment K.1a Cathodic Protection Rectifiers Narrative_2.23. (852.8 KB)
- Exhibit A.210 Response to County questions - T3-2022-16220 (1.06 MB)
- Exhibit A.211 A.1a Flysheet (14.83 KB)
- Exhibit A.212 A.1a Site Plans (47.47 MB)[Filtration Facility]
- Exhibit A.213 A.2a Flysheet (14.92 KB)
- Exhibit A.214 Appendix A.2a Site Plans (20.35 MB) [Pipeline Plans]
- Exhibit A.215 Bull Run Filtration Pipelines_Stormwater Report Addendum (490.55 KB)
- Exhibit A.216 T3-2022-16220 3-24-23 Memo (367.87 KB)
- Exhibit A.217 1.C Communications Tower Conditional Use and Design Review Application Narrative_April 2023 (12.73 MB)
- Exhibit A.218 Email re Bldg Permits for Lusted Hill Distribution Main (715.88 KB)
- Exhibit A.219 T3-2022-16220 4-28-23 Memo (525.7 KB)
- Exhibit A.220 T3-2022-16220 4-28-23 Certification of Water Service (494.31 KB)
- Exhibit A.221 T3-2022-16220 4-28-23 Location of Drain Fields on Raw Water Pipeline Properties (359.68 KB)
- Exhibit A.222 T3-2022-16220 5-3-23 Memo (282.26 KB)
- Exhibit A.223 T3-2022-16220 5-3-23 Tower Supplemental Attachment 1 (183.41 KB)
- Exhibit A.224 T3-2022-16220 5-3-23 Tower Supplemental Attachment 2 (474.51 KB)
- Exhibit A.225 T3-2022-16220 5.8.23 Memo (2.48 MB)
- Exhibit A.226 Appendix - Traffic Count Data (49.79 MB)
- Exhibit A.227 Bull Run Filtration Construction Traffic Impact Analysis (6.14 MB)
- Exhibit A.228 LRDM route and SEC rec'd 6.2.23 (119.35 KB)
- Exhibit A.229 LU-200 symbology clarification rec'd 6.2.23 (116.48 KB)
- Exhibit A.230 Bull Run Filtration Construction Traffic Impact Analysis_6.2.23 (15.22 MB)
Staff Exhibits
- Exhibit B.1 1962 - 10.5.1977 Zoning 1s4e22 (126.61 KB)
- Exhibit B.2 Zoning Districts ZO 1974-5-17 (104.14 KB)
- Exhibit B.3 F2 Zone 1974-5-17 (111.47 KB)
- Exhibit B.4 Current Tax Map 1S4E22D (36.15 KB)
- Exhibit B.5 Warranty Deed B1025 P516 (810.81 KB)
- Exhibit B.6 Parcel Record Card for R994220930 (2.23 MB)
- Exhibit B.7 T2-2010-1052 Decision (519.95 KB)
- Exhibit B.8 T2-2015-4092 (374.7 KB)
- Exhibit B.9 Partition Plat 1991-111 (161.74 KB)
- Exhibit B.10 Edgewater Subdivision Plat 1912 (329.11 KB)
- Exhibit B.11 T3-06-003 Hearing Officer Dec (2.88 MB)
- Exhibit B.12 County Engineer Letter (109.83 KB)
- Exhibit B.13 EP-2023-16844-PWB-Transportation-memo (351.56 KB)
- Exhibit B.14 Probability of Liquefaction Map (356.57 KB)
- Exhibit B.15 Earthquake Damage Potential (372.49 KB)
- Exhibit B.16 Revised EP-2023-16844-PWB-Transportation-Memo (347.81 KB)
Procedural Exhibits
- Exhibit C.1 T3-2022-16220 Incomplete Letter 11.10.2022 (1.79 MB)
- Exhibit C.2 T3-2022-16220 Applicant Response Letter 11.15.2022 (248.36 KB)
- Exhibit C.3 T3-2022-16220 Complete Letter 02.28.2023 (767.82 KB)
- Exhibit C.4 T3-2022-16220 OTC 03.31.2023 (1.96 MB)
- Exhibit C.5 T3-2022-16220 Hearing Notice Information (8.62 MB)
- Exhibit C.6 T3-2022-16220 Bull Run Filtration Notice Posting Exhibit (1.54 MB)
Public Comments
- Exhibit D.1 Fire District 10 Comments 1.03.2023 (9.56 MB)
- Exhibit D.2 GBSD Email rec'd 3.3.23 (1.35 MB)
- Exhibit D.3 GBSD PWB Water Treatment Plant Opposition Resolution SIGNED rec'd 3.3.23 (473.75 KB)
- Exhibit D.4 Nerison Comment 3.6.23 (575.5 KB)
- Exhibit D.5 Ekstrom Comment dated 3.14.23 rec 3.21.23 (682.63 KB)
- Exhibit D.6 Surface Nursery - Farm Impacts Letter 4.4.23 (676.78 KB)
- Exhibit D.7 Kost Comment 4.17.23 (279.42 KB)
- Exhibit D.8 Swinford Comment 4.17.23 (1.31 MB)
- Exhibit D.9 Allott Comment rec 4.21.23 (654.45 KB)
- Exhibit D.10 Cottrell Community Planning Organization Comment rec 4.21.23 (981.79 KB)
- Exhibit D.11 Cottrell CPO Email submitting Resolutions rec 4.21.23 (694.28 KB)
- Exhibit D.12 Cottrell CPO Resolution rec 4.21.23 (407.47 KB)
- Exhibit D.13 PHCA Comments - PWB water plant rec 4.21.23 (486.1 KB)
- Exhibit D.14 PHCA Resolution rec 4.21.23 (917.17 KB)
- Exhibit D.15 Gale - Bacon Comment 5.2.23 (1.47 MB)
- Exhibit D.16 Gresham Fire Comments rec 6.5.23 (612.77 KB)
- Exhibit D.17 OHA Comments rec 6.12.23 (433.62 KB)
- Exhibit D.18 Grahn Comments rec 6.12.23 (99.21 KB)
- Exhibit D.19 Wilson Comment rec 6.12.23 (108.63 KB)
- Exhibit D.20 Oregon Trail School District Comment rec 6.12.23 (330 KB)
- Exhibit D.21 Jessen Comment rec 6.14.23 (106.39 KB)
- Exhibit D.22 Oregon Trail School District Addendum rec 6.14.23 (337.01 KB)
- Exhibit D.23 Woodward Comment rec 6.19.23 (105.59 KB)
Exhibits Submitted Post Staff Report Issuance
- Exhibit E.1 Hart Testimony rec 6.26.23 (149.61 KB)
- Exhibit E.2 Jessen Testimony rec 6.26.23 (106.24 KB)
- Exhibit E.3 Hart Testimony Continued rec 6.27.23 (274.41 KB)
- Exhibit E.4 P Lewis MD Testimony rec 6.27.23 (450.78 KB)
- Exhibit E.5 Mulkey Testimony rec 6.27.23 (108.91 KB)
- Exhibit E.6 P Lewis MD Testimony - Revised rec 6.27.23 (244.78 KB)
- Exhibit E.7 Riegelmann Testimony rec 6.28.23 (91.34 KB)
- Exhibit E.8 Tammy Rickman, First Student Testimony rec 6.28.23 (608.27 KB)
- Exhibit E.9 Charles Ciecko Testimony rec 6.28.23 (24.51 MB)
- Exhibit E.10 Rural Fire Protection Dist #10 Supplemental Testimony rec 6.28.23 (5.55 MB)
- Exhibit E.11 Voruz Testimony rec 6.28.23 (101.42 KB)
- Exhibit E.12 G Allott Testimony rec 6.28.23 (96.88 KB)
- Exhibit E.13 J Allott Testimony rec 6.28.23 (100.92 KB)
- Exhibit E.14 Grace Allott Testimony rec 6.28.23 (96.44 KB)
- Exhibit E.15 Cindy Bennington Testimony 6.29.23 (2.5 MB)
- Exhibit E.16 Park Testimony 6.29.2023 (878.23 KB)
- Exhibit E.17 Lauren Courter Land Use Testimony 6.29.2023 (5.49 MB)
- Exhibit E.18 Cris Courter Written Testimony 6.29.2023 (27.66 KB)
- Exhibit E.19 Ian Courter Land Use Statement 6.29.2023 (716.68 KB)
- Exhibit E.20 Suzanne Courter Written Testimony 6.29.2023 (24.83 KB)
- Exhibit E.21 T Carlson Project Geologist rec 6.29.23 (2.38 MB)
- Exhibit E.22 Dahl Testimony rec 6.29.23 (101.91 KB)
- Exhibit E.23 J Coker Sandy Public Works Dir Testimony rec 6.29.23 (106.22 KB)
- Exhibit E.24 Dept of Agriculture - J Johnson Testimony rec 6.29.23 (348.38 KB)
- Exhibit E.25 Keathley Testimony rec 6.29.23 (108.58 KB)
- Exhibit E.26 Dan Brink Testimony rec 6.29.23 (167.99 KB)
- Exhibit E.27 M Persons Testimony rec 6.29.23 (105.5 KB)
- Exhibit E.28 LJ McFarlane Testimony rec 6.29.23 (132.89 KB)
- Exhibit E.29 M Dahl Testimony rec 6.29.23 (115.8 KB)
- Exhibit E.30 Gresham Barlow School District - K Howatt Testimony rec 6.29.2023 (203.63 KB)
- Exhibit E.31 Emily Hafer Testimony, Revised rec 6.29.23 (142.74 KB)
- Exhibit E.32 C Waugh Testimony rec 6.29.23 (207.12 KB)
- Exhibit E.33 Moldovanyl Testimony rec 6.29.23 (109.97 KB)
- Exhibit E.34 Pool Testimony rec 6.29.23 (101.09 KB)
- Exhibit E.35 Bartha Testimony rec 6.29.23 (97.35 KB)
- Exhibit E.36 Shawn Nerison Testimony rec 6.29.23 (143.37 KB)
- Exhibit E.37 Cottrell Community Planning Organization Submittal
- Exhibit E.37.a Diack Photos rec 6.29.23 (1.27 MB)
- Exhibit E.37.b Oregon Trail Academy Photos rec 6.29.23 (671.37 KB)
- Exhibit E.37.c Reynolds HS PM Traffic rec 6.29.23 (186.05 KB)
- Exhibit E.37.d Sandy HS PM Pickup Photos rec 6.29.23 (159.01 KB)
- Exhibit E.37.e Community Opposition Petitions rec 6.29.23 (27.22 MB)
- Exhibit E.37.f Bear & Cougar Photos rec 6.29.23 (605.77 KB)
- Exhibit E.37.g Accident Dodge Park Blvd & Cottrell rec 6.29.23 (173.85 KB)
- Exhibit E.37.h Size of Plant vs Largest Nurseries and Scenic Fruit rec 6.29.23 (170.45 KB)
- Exhibit E.37.i Photo of Coyote Pups rec 6.29.23 (199.63 KB)
- Exhibit E.37.j Cottrell CPO Drone Footage rec 6.29.23 (35.99 MB)
- Exhibit E.37.k Johnson Creek Headwaters Photos rec 6.29.23 (315 KB)
- Exhibit E.37.l PWB Site Nature Photos rec 6.29.23 (1.21 MB)
- Exhibit E.37.m Bear and Deer Photos rec 6.29.23 (448.9 KB)
- Exhibit E.37.n East Orient School Photos rec 6.29.23 (1.04 MB)
- Exhibit E.37.o Various Animal Photos rec 6.29.23 (888.46 KB)
- Exhibit E.37.p OTA Photos rec 6.29.23 (125.1 KB)
- Exhibit E.37.q Sam Barlow HS Photos rec 6.29.23 (1.44 MB)
- Exhibit E.37.r Sandy HS PM Aerial Photos rec 6.29.23 (984.73 KB)
- Exhibit E.37.s West Orient School Photos rec 6.29.23 (697.11 KB)
- Exhibit E.38 Cottrell Community Planning Organization Videos
- Exhibit E.38.a COTA Evening Walk Carpenter Lane Video
- Exhibit E.38.b Dangerous Detour Route Video
- Exhibit E.38.c Night Sky 34828 Carpenter Lane Video
- Exhibit E.38.d Night Sky RH Nursery Video
- Exhibit E.38.e Carpenter Lane Night Sky Video
- Exhibit E.38.f Refuting PWB Night Sky Report Video
- Exhibit E.38.g Traffic Dodge Park Video
- Exhibit E.38.h Carpenter Lane Widening Proposal COTA Video
- Exhibit E.38.i Carpenter Lane Widening Proposal Video
- Exhibit E.38.j Dodge Park Blvd Drone Video
- Exhibit E.38.k Culver COTA Video
- Exhibit E.38.l Culver COTA Video 2
- Exhibit E.38.m 36014 SE Lusted Rd Elk Video dated April 2, 2023
Hearing Exhibits
- Exhibit H.1 June 30 Memorandum to the Hearings Officer from Land Use Planning (886.88 KB)
- Exhibit H.2 Memorandum to the Hearings Officer from Pleasant Home Neighborhood Association Attorney Jeffrey Kleinman (178.97 KB)
- Exhibit H.3 Pre-Hearing Statement by the Applicant (50.29 MB)
- Exhibit H.4 Memorandum to the Hearings Officer from Cottrell Community Planning Organization Attorney Carrie Richter (203.42 KB)
- Exhibit H.5 Memorandum to the Hearings Officer from Shelley Ekstrom (822.55 KB)
- Exhibit H.6 Memorandum to the Hearings Officer from Cindy Bennington (2.2 MB)
- Exhibit H.7 Written Testimony by Andrea Culver (1.11 MB)
- Exhibit H.8 Technical Memorandum to the Hearings Officer from Michael Ard (8.59 MB)
- Exhibit H.9 Memorandum to the Hearings Officer from Brent Leathers (1.67 MB)
- Exhibit H.10 Written Testimony by Terry Ciecko (932.17 KB)
- Exhibit H.11 Memorandum to the Hearings Officer by Andrew Mulkey, Staff Attorney for 1000 Friends of Oregon (1.12 MB)
- Exhibit H.12 Memorandum to the Hearings Officer by Paul Willis (10.32 MB)
- Exhibit H.13 Memorandum to the Hearings Officer by Lucia Willis (997.7 KB)
- Exhibit H.14 Written Testimony from Suzanne Courter (1.02 MB)
- Exhibit H.15 Written Testimony from John Edmondson (804.05 KB)
- Exhibit H.16 Written Testimony from Holly H. Martin (4.02 MB)
- Exhibit H.17 Pictures of Arrowheads and Tools provided by Christy McKenzie rec 6.30.23 (222.81 KB)
- Exhibit H.18 Meyer Family Arrow Collection submitted by Lauren Courter (305.41 KB)
- Exhibit H.19 Aerial Map submitted by Charles Waugh (470.78 KB)
- Exhibit H.20 Meyer Family Arrow Collection submitted by Lauren Courter (Part 2) (197.91 KB)
- Exhibit H.21 Written Testimony from Larry Bailey (110.76 KB)
- Exhibit H.22 Evidence from Paul Willis regarding Accident Dodge Park & Cottrell rec 6.30.23 (358.38 KB)
- Exhibit H.22.a Written Testimony from R&H Nursery Inc Owner Patrick Holt rec 6.30.23 (2.25 MB)
- Exhibit H.22.b Written Testimony from Julie Allott rec 6.30.23 (260.54 KB)
- Exhibit H.22.c Written Testimony from Mary Appelt rec 6.30.23 (215.49 KB)
- Exhibit H.22.d Written Testimony from Jeff & Mona Ayles rec 6.30.23 (501.24 KB)
- Exhibit H.22.e Written Testimony from Rick & Carol Bartha rec 6.30.23 (584.1 KB)
- Exhibit H.22.f Written Testimony from Laura Belson rec 6.30.23 (1.02 MB)
- Exhibit H.23 Written Testimony from Kelsey Betsil rec 6.30.23 (550.43 KB)
- Exhibit H.23.a Written Testimony from Laura Beving rec 6.30.23 (241 KB)
- Exhibit H.23.b Written Testimony from Kathleen Box rec 6.30.23 (259.81 KB)
- Exhibit H.23.c Written Testimony from Dan Brink rec 6.30.23 (782.14 KB)
- Exhibit H.23.d Written Testimony from Jim & Theresa Bunting rec 6.30.23 (351.66 KB)
- Exhibit H.23.e Written Testimony from Terry Ciecko rec 6.30.23 (282.87 KB)
- Exhibit H.23.f Written Testimony from Oriah Columbres rec 6.30.23 (186.27 KB)
- Exhibit H.23.g Written Testimony from Angela Parker rec 6.30.23 (394.67 KB)
- Exhibit H.23.h Written Testimony from Kenneth & Patsy Carlson rec 6.30.23 (385.43 KB)
- Exhibit H.23.i Written Testimony from Cris Courter rec 6.30.23 (498.6 KB)
- Exhibit H.23.j Written Testimony from Lauren Courter rec 6.30.23 (325.27 KB)
- Exhibit H.23.k Written Testimony from Cris Courter rec 6.30.23 (498.6 KB)
- Exhibit H.24 Written Testimony from Andrea Culver rec 6.30.23 (234.36 KB)
- Exhibit H.24.a Written Testimony from Braeden Culver rec 6.30.23 (345.15 KB)
- Exhibit H.24.b Written Testimony from Katrina Dawson rec 6.30.23 (554.72 KB)
- Exhibit H.24.c Written Testimony from Mike Dawson rec 6.30.23 (191.86 KB)
- Exhibit H.24.d Written Testimony from Samuel Diack rec 6.30.23 (914.52 KB)
- Exhibit H.24.e Written Testimony from Gloria Driscoll rec 6.30.23 (178.38 KB)
- Exhibit H.24.f Written Testimony from Ed Evans rec 6.30.23 (278.38 KB)
- Exhibit H.24.g Written Testimony from Patricia Fiedler rec 6.30.23 (321.48 KB)
- Exhibit H.24.h Written Testimony from Darren & Michelle Ford rec 6.30.23 (130.38 KB)
- Exhibit H.24.i Written Testimony from Amy Galasso rec 6.30.23 (225.87 KB)
- Exhibit H.24.j Written Testimony from Robert Galasso, MD rec 6.30.23 (484.99 KB)
- Exhibit H.24.k Written Testimony from Penny Kay & Michael Haight rec 6.30.23 (266.89 KB)
- Exhibit H.24.l Written Testimony from Jennifer Hart rec 6.30.23 (1.11 MB)
- Exhibit H.25 Written Testimony from Tom Newberry rec 6.30.23 (512.03 KB)
- Exhibit H.25.a Written Testimony from Kathleen Obrist rec 6.30.23 (219.94 KB)
- Exhibit H.25.b Written Testimony from Emily Hafer OR Trail Academy rec 6.30.23 (305.25 KB)
- Exhibit H.25.c Written Testimony from Jodi Riehl rec 6.30.23 (638.22 KB)
- Exhibit H.25.d Written Testimony from Victoria Hutfilz rec 6.30.23 (216.59 KB)
- Exhibit H.25.e Written Testimony from Sharon Jones rec 6.30.23 (264.59 KB)
- Exhibit H.25.f Written Testimony from Mike & Carol Kost rec 6.30.23 (192.19 KB)
- Exhibit H.25.g Written Testimony from The Kramers rec 6.30.23 (613.6 KB)
- Exhibit H.26 Written Testimony from Debbie Layton rec 6.30.23 (315.91 KB)
- Exhibit H.26.a Written Testimony from Jamie Martin rec 6.30.23-3 (548.2 KB)
- Exhibit H.26.b Written Testimony from Doug and Pat Meyer rec 6.30.23 (492.58 KB)
- Exhibit H.26.c Written Testimony from Kaitlin Mulkey rec 6.30.23 (512.24 KB)
- Exhibit H.26.d Written Testimony from Jesse Nelson rec 6.30.23 (277.31 KB)
- Exhibit H.26.e Written Testimony from Leslie Newberry rec 6.30.23 (810.47 KB)
- Exhibit H.27 Written Testimony from Diane Rolen rec 6.30.23 (843.67 KB)
- Exhibit H.28 Written Testimony and Photos from David Shapiro rec 6.30.23 (1.69 MB)
- Exhibit H.28.a Written Testimony from Clackamas County Commissioner Mark Shull rec 6.30.23 (557.29 KB)
- Exhibit H.28.b Written Testimony from John Sieling rec 6.30.23 (161.39 KB)
- Exhibit H.28.c Written Testimony from Susan & John Swinford rec 6.30.23 (862.2 KB)
- Exhibit H.29 Written Testimony from Kristy McKenzie rec 6.30.23 (888.2 KB)
- Exhibit H.30 Written Testimony from Charles Waugh rec 6.30.23 (1008.14 KB)
- Exhibit H.30.a Written Testimony from Debra Westcott rec 6.30.23 (206.32 KB)
- Exhibit H.30.b Written Testimony from Deborah Wilson rec 6.30.23 (258.72 KB)
- Exhibit H.31 Current Sound Measurements on Proposed Filtration Site dated 6-25-2023 (1.31 MB)
- Exhibit H.32 Review of Archaeological Investigations for Carpenter Lane Project (928.73 KB)
- Exhibit H.32.a Arden Meyer Interview dated 02-28-2023 (2.37 MB)
- Exhibit H.32.b Annell Carlson Interview dated 06-14-2023 (823.43 KB)
- Exhibit H.33 Transcript of 4-13-23 Portland Water Bureau Work Session (490.19 KB)
- Exhibit H.34 Written Testimony from Holly Martin rec 6.30.23 (2.94 MB)
- Exhibit H.35 Written Testimony from Brent Leathers (423.72 KB)
- Exhibit H.36 Written Testimony from Kyza Nelson (234.92 KB)
- Exhibit H.37 OAN Email Request- I would formally request that the record be held open for comments (178.45 KB)
- Exhibit H.38 Written Testimony from Ryan Marjama, Don Marjama Nursery (314.93 KB)
- Exhibit H.39 Written Testimony from David Shapiro rec 6.30.23 (9 MB)
- Exhibit H.40 Rural Filtration Plants Comparison Data from CCPO (439.35 KB)
- Exhibit H.41 Written Testimony from Patricia Walter rec 6.30.23 (715.72 KB)
- Exhibit H.42 PWB PowerPoint Presentation from Public Hearing (5.04 MB)
Post Hearing Exhibits - New Evidence Period
- Exhibit I.1 Ekstrom Testimony rec 7.2.23 (99.58 KB)
- Exhibit I.2 Clackamas Cty Decision Z0036-23 regarding Emergency Access Road rec 7.5.23 (1.73 MB)
- Exhibit I.3 CCPO Carpenter Lane - Traffic will get detoured through rec 7.7.23 (249.6 KB)
- Exhibit I.4 Written Testimony from Scott Eck rec 7.13.23 (105.32 KB)
- Exhibit I.5 Email from Jodi Riehl rec 7.16.23 (463.13 KB)
- Exhibit I.6 Oregon's Mt. Hood Scenic Byway Addendum from Cindy Bennington rec 7.21.23. (6.34 MB)
- Exhibit I.7 Citizens for Peaceful Rural Living Video
- Exhibit I.7.a Additional Testimony in Opposition from Brent Leathers rec 7.27.23 (275.22 KB)
- Exhibit I.8 Supplemental Testimony of Holly Martin rec 8.1.23 (257.98 KB)
- Exhibit I.9 Bull Run Filtration Facility Fire Protection Strategy Letter from Gresham Fire Chief Scott Lewis rec 8.2.23 (441.08 KB)
- Exhibit I.10 Mult. Rural Fire Prot. District #10 Supplemental Testimony rec 08.03.2003. (3.37 MB)
- Exhibit I.11 Ekstrom Rebuttal to PWB Treatment Plant rec 8.3.23 (279.83 KB)
- Exhibit I.11.a Pipeline Installation Effects on Soils and Plants _ A Review and Quantitative Synthesis rec 8.3.23 (491.23 KB)
- Exhibit I.11.b FY-2019-20-Water-Demand-and-Sales rec 8.3.23 (184.21 KB)
- Exhibit I.11.c Pipeline Study Shows Soil Compaction and Crop Yield Impact in Construction Right-of-Ways rec 8.3.23 (155.68 KB)
- Exhibit I.11.d Pipelines keep robbing the land long after the bulldozers leave _ Grist rec 8.3.23 (8.79 MB)
- Exhibit I.12 Gresham Barlow School District Supplemental Testimony in Opposition rec 08.03.2023 (438.69 KB)
- Exhibit I.13 OR Association of Nurseries Written Testimony rec 8.3.23 (527.01 KB)
- Exhibit I.13.a Address Locations of Nursery Licenses Map rec 8.3.23 (5.19 MB)
- Exhibit I.13.b Location of Agriculture Operations rec 8.3.23 (5.17 MB)
- Exhibit I.13.c Relationship of Agriculture Lands to Roads Utilized for Development rec 8.3.23 (5.19 MB)
- Exhibit I.13.d LCDC Approved Metro Designated Rural Reserves Map rec 8.3.23 (633.67 KB)
- Exhibit I.13.e OWRD Groundwater Limited Areas Info rec 8.3.23 (352.47 KB)
- Exhibit I.14 Z Powers Email regarding Water Bureau Clearwell rec 8.4.23 (219.2 KB)
- Exhibit I.15 Mark Johnson Written Testimony rec 8.4.23 (97.08 KB)
- Exhibit I.16 Kress Drew Written Testimony rec 8.4.23 (102.68 KB)
- Exhibit I.17 Michael Cowan Written Testimony rec 8.5.23 (116.72 KB)
- Exhibit I.18 Tammy Rickman Written Testimony rec 8.5.23 (193.4 KB)
- Exhibit I.19 Patricia Fielder Written Testimony rec 8.5.23 (102.5 KB)
- Exhibit I.20 Ken Smith Testimony submitted by Paul Willis rec 8.5.23 (105.54 KB)
- Exhibit I.21 L. Belson Testimony rec 8.5.23 (19.07 MB)
- Exhibit I.22 L Belson Testimony rec 8.6.23 (341.91 KB)
- Exhibit I.22.a Night Sky May 23 Pleasant Home Water Towers 1 Video
- Exhibit I.22.b Night Sky Carpenter Lane Site Looking North Video
- Exhibit I.22.c Night Sky Photos (4 MB)
- Exhibit I.22.d Video Captions to the Record rec 8.6.23 (75.3 KB)
- Exhibit I.22.e Night Sky East C-Lane Video
- Exhibit I.22.f Photos Carpenter Ln - Detour and Night Sky (2.56 MB)
- Exhibit I.23 William and Nicki Meyers Written Testimony rec 8.6.23 (97.91 KB)
- Exhibit I.24 Cindy Bennington Written Testimony rec 8.6.23 (1.53 MB)
- Exhibit I.25 Cottrell CPO Testimony re Cultural & Archeological Resources rec 8.6.23 (126.14 KB)
- Exhibit I.26 CCPO Traffic Conditions - Schools Testimony rec 8.6.23 (3.39 MB)
- Exhibit I.27 Tanner & Macy Davis Written Testimony rec 8.6.23 (208.99 KB)
- Exhibit I.28 Jennifer Hart Testimony re Hazardous Conditions & Retaining Wall rec 8.6.23 (1.44 MB)
- Exhibit I.29 Black Gold Springs - J Hart Farm Impacts Emergency Road Testimony rec 8.6.23 (114.55 KB)
- Exhibit I.30 Kristen Markham Written Testimony rec 8.6.23 (140.38 KB)
- Exhibit I.31 Surface Nursery Farmer Impact Statement - Shawn Nerison with Maps rec 8.6.23. (558.18 KB)
- Exhibit I.32 Ron Roberts Written Testimony rec 8.6.23 (390.77 KB)
- Exhibit I.33 Ronald Ruedi Written Testimony rec 8.6.23 (142.07 KB)
- Exhibit I.34 Angela Parker, Hawk Haven Equine Written Testimony rec 8.6.23 (289.13 KB)
- Exhibit I.35 Attorney Kleinman Written Testimony representing Pleasant Home Comm Assoc rec 8.7.23 (432.1 KB)
- Exhibit I.36 Sharon Jones Written Testimony rec 8.7.23 (102.18 KB)
- Exhibit I.37 Pat Meyer Written Testimony rec 8.7.23 (169.6 KB)
- Exhibit I.38 Hans Nelson & Sons Nursery Written Testimony rec 8.7.23 (423.61 KB)
- Exhibit I.39 Cottrell CPO Sound Impacts Testimony rec 8.7.23 (212.26 KB)
- Exhibit I.40 Cottrell CPO Written Testimony rec 8.7.23 (1.07 MB)
- Exhibit I.41 Grahn Written Testimony rec 8.7.23 (104.31 KB)
- Exhibit I.42 Wensenk Written Testimony rec 8.7.23 (408.03 KB)
- Exhibit I.43 Brittney & Aaron Cory, Free Rein Stables Written Testimony rec 8.7.23 (150.26 KB)
- Exhibit I.44 Les Poole Written Testimony rec 8.7.23 (110.3 KB)
- Exhibit I.45 Land Use Planning Post Hearing Memo to Hearings Officer rec 8.7.23 (253.85 KB)
- Exhibit I.46 Ard Engineering_PWB Mitigation Plan Review rec 8.7.23 (720.47 KB)
- Exhibit I.47 Mona & Jeff Ayles Supplemental Testimony rec 8.7.23 (1015.45 KB)
- Exhibit I.48 Terry Ciecko Written Testimony rec 8.7.23 (122.96 KB)
- Exhibit I.49 Suzanne Courter Written Testimony rec 8.7.23 (3.64 MB)
- Exhibit I.50 TreeSource Response to Construction Farm Traffic Report rec 8.7.23 (368.56 KB)
- Exhibit I.51 Surface Nursery Written Testimony regarding Exhibit H.3 rec 8.7.23 (364.73 KB)
- Exhibit I.52 Ken Carlson, Carlson Farms Written Testimony rec 8.7.23 (203.42 KB)
- Exhibit I.53 R & H Nursery Written Testimony regarding PWB Construction rec 8.7.23 (896.97 KB)
- Exhibit I.54 Emily Hafer, OR Trail Academy Written Testimony rec 8.7.23 (272.7 KB)
- Exhibit I.55 Ian & Lauren Courter Written Testimony rec 8.7.23 (6.57 MB)
- Exhibit I.56 Brent Leathers Supplement Testimony Truck Routes rec 8.7.23 (1.87 MB)
- Exhibit I.57 Water Filtration Facility Land Use Plans (14.38 MB)
- Exhibit I.58 Supplemental Info for the Hazardous Materials Management Plan (254.54 KB)
- Exhibit I.59 Hazardous Management Plan revision date 8.4.23 (5.81 MB)
- Exhibit I.60 Overflow Basin Overview (474.8 KB)
- Exhibit I.61 Supplemental Info re Concrete Backfill in Finished Water Pipelines (231.07 KB)
- Exhibit I.62 Supplemental Info re Concrete in the Raw Water Pipelines rec 8.7.23 (162.77 KB)
- Exhibit I.63 Supplemental Info regarding Existing Water Wells rec 8.7.23 (365.11 KB)
- Exhibit I.64 Effect of Raw Water Pipeline & Tunnels on the Local Water Wells rec 8.7.23 (2.37 MB)
- Exhibit I.65 Supplemental Geotechnical Information rec 8.7.23 (28.78 MB)
- Exhibit I.66 Supplemental Info regarding Expansive Soils rec 8.7.23 (1.74 MB)
- Exhibit I.67 Supplemental Info re Expansive Soils & Fat Clay rec 8.7.23 (10.8 MB)
- Exhibit I.68 Draft Exhibit G Legal Description for Permanent Access Easement rec 8.7.23 (265.17 KB)
- Exhibit I.69 Draft Exhibit Legal Description for a Temp Access Easement rec 8.7.23 (208.03 KB)
- Exhibit I.70 Decision of the Hearings Officer for T3-2017-9259 rec 8.7.23 (1.02 MB)
- Exhibit I.71 Decision of Hearings Officer for T3-2019-11405 rec 8.7.23 (884.54 KB)
- Exhibit I.72 Decision of Hearings Officer for T3-2019-11784 rec 8.7.23 (1.13 MB)
- Exhibit I.73 Notice of Hearings Officer Decision T2-2019-12701 rec 8.7.23 (412.84 KB)
- Exhibit I.74 Filtration Facility Operations Supplemental Info rec.8.7.23 (1.04 MB)
- Exhibit I.75 Construction Supplemental Info rec 8.7.23 (1.11 MB)
- Exhibit I.76 Deed for Road Purposes rec 8.7.23 (663.91 KB)
- Exhibit I.77 Warranty Deed Instrument #2015-079565 rec 8.7.23 (224.87 KB)
- Exhibit I.78 City of Fresno, CA vs Carollo rec 8.7.23 (379.77 KB)
- Exhibit I.79 Water Treatment Facility Construction rec 8.7.23 (192.44 KB)
- Exhibit I.80 Response to Public Comments Related to Farm Use Impacts in Mult Cty rec 8.7.23 (15.86 MB)
- Exhibit I.81 Response to Testimony of Agricultural Soils Impact rec 8.7.23 (991.54 KB)
- Exhibit I.82 Attachment 27: Video of Truck driving on Existing Farm Road on Portland Water Bureau Property on Carpenter Lane
- Exhibit I.83 Response to Select Testimony from Allan Felsot to PWB rec 8.7.23 (901.38 KB)
- Exhibit I.84 Response to Select Testimony from Dana Beckwith, Global Transportation Engineering on Transportation Impacts rec 8.7.23 (653.5 KB)
- Exhibit I.85 Pictures of Trucks on Roads, Private Property and Cars Parking on Private Property rec 8.7.23 (1.45 MB)
- Exhibit I.86 Water Filtration Facility Carpenter Lane One-Access Analysis Update to Construction TIA rec 8.7.23 (425.71 KB)
- Exhibit I.87 Supplemental Information about Chemical Safety rec 8.7.23 (496.68 KB)
- Exhibit I.88 Consultant Resumes rec 8.7.23 (4.77 MB)
- Exhibit I.89 Intergovernmental Agreement for Fire Services between Gresham and Fire District #10 - Unsigned rec 8.7.23 (111.79 KB)
- Exhibit I.90 Structural Fire Districts rec 8.7.23 (162.46 KB)
- Exhibit I.91 Fire Protection & Life Safety 3rd Party Consulting Review rec 8.7.23 (10.07 MB)
- Exhibit I.92 Response to Exhibit E.21 concerning Stormwater Runoff to Beaver Creek rec 8.7.23 (4.61 MB)
- Exhibit I.93 Alternative Routes for Distribution to Avoid SEC-h Zone rec 8.7.23 (200.77 KB)
- Exhibit I.94 Climate Change Considerations in Design of Stormwater Management Systems Technical Memo rec 8.7.23 (2.32 MB)
- Exhibit I.95 Best Management Practices to Protect Johnson & Beaver Creeks Memo rec 8.7.23 (1.07 MB)
- Exhibit I.96 Potential Wildlife Habitat Impacts from the Water Filtration Project and Measures for Avoidance and Mitigation rec 8.7.23 (5.78 MB)
- Exhibit I.97 SEC-H RW-01 Area (LU-601M) & SEC-H Lusted Hill Plan (LU-602M) rec 8.7.23 (3.23 MB)
- Exhibit I.98 Response to Paul Solimano, Willamette Cultural Resources Associates rec 8.7.23 (20.8 MB)
- Exhibit I.99 Stormwater Evidence Cover Memo rec 8.7.23 (13.73 MB)
- Exhibit I.100 Erosion Control Plans for Water Filtration Facility and Carpenter Lane rec 8.7.23 (12.7 MB)
- Exhibit I.101 Erosion & Sediment Control Plans for Pipeline Installations rec 8.7.23 (13.09 MB)
- Exhibit I.102 Finished Water Pipeline Erosion and Sediment Control Plans for Grids 8 – 16, Intertie Site rec 8.7.23 (15.62 MB)
- Exhibit I.103 Consultant Report 2022 Community Risk Assessment & Standards of Coverage for Gresham Fire rec 8.7.23. (24.62 MB)
- Exhibit I.104 Verification of Date of Time of PWB Document Submittals rec 8.7.23 (710.53 KB)
Post Hearing Exhibits - Rebuttal Period
- Exhibit J.1 ODA Response to PWB Rebuttal Comments rec 8.30.23 (224.77 KB)
- Exhibit J.2 Patricia Fiedler Rebuttal Testimony rec 9.2.23 (111.26 KB)
- Exhibit J.3 Angela Parker Hawk Haven Rebuttal Testimony rec 9.5.23 (212.85 KB)
- Exhibit J.4 Jennifer Hart Rebuttal Response to Exhibit I.80 rec 9.5.23 (2.33 MB)
- Exhibit J.5 Jennifer Hart Rebuttal Response to Exhibit I.81 rec 9.5.23 (179.78 KB)
- Exhibit J.6 Tammy Rickman, First Student Rebuttal Testimony rec 9.5.23 (306.39 KB)
- Exhibit J.7 Charles Ciecko Rebuttal Testimony rec 9.5.23 (190.61 KB)
- Exhibit J.8 Rod Park, Park's Nursery Rebuttal Testimony rec 9.5.2023 (1.56 MB)
- Exhibit J.9 Gresham Barlow School Board Rebuttal Testimony rec 9.5.23 (321.04 KB)
- Exhibit J.10 Holly Martin Rebuttal Testimony rec 9.6.23 (169.63 KB)
- Exhibit J.11 Holly Martin Amendment to Supplemental Testimony Provided in Exhibit I.8 rec 9.6.23 (236.69 KB)
- Exhibit J.12 Jeffrey Kleinman on behalf of PHCA Rebuttal Testimony rec 9.6.23 (246.99 KB)
- Exhibit J.13 Jesse Nelson, Hans Nelson & Sons Nursery Rebuttal Testimony Rec 9.6.23 (393.88 KB)
- Exhibit J.14 CCPO Response to Staff Report - Mult Code vs Plan rec 9.6.23 (113.27 KB)
- Exhibit J.15 CCPO Rebuttal to I.91 David Stacy rec 9.6.23 (243.33 KB)
- Exhibit J.16 CCPO Rebuttal to Exhibit A.35 Soil Restoration rec 9.6.23 (1.47 MB)
- Exhibit J.17 CCPO Rebuttal to Exhibit I.79 Comparable Facilities rec 9.6.23 (131.66 KB)
- Exhibit J.18 CCPO Rebuttal to Exhibit I.98 Archeology rec 9.6.23 (226.36 KB)
- Exhibit J.19 Impacts of PWB's Proposed Filtration Plant on Johnson Creek & Neighboring Waterways prepared by CCPO rec 9.6.23 (8.33 MB)
- Exhibit J.20 JC Report Dec-24-21-Pond.MOV submitted by CCPO
- Exhibit J.21 CCPO Rebuttal to Exhibits I.74 I.75 and I.82 rec 9.6.23 (16.82 MB)
- Exhibit J.22 Richard Carson, Sunshine Nursery Rebuttal to Exhibit I.80 Sunshine Nursery rec 9.6.23 (5.12 MB)
- Exhibit J.23 MWH-Kiewit JV for Bull Run Filtration Facility Project Construction Procurement Report 00001428 submitted by CCPO rec 9.6.23 (1.28 MB)
- Exhibit J.24 Verification of Date & Time of CCPO Submittals rec 9.6.23 (504.15 KB)
- Exhibit J.25 Video 1.0 Large Trucks are Dangerous in Rural Areas submitted by CCPO
- Exhibit J.26 Video 2.0 Carpenter Lane is a Rural Residential LANE submitted by CCPO
- Exhibit J.27 Video 3.0 Large Trucks and Farm Traffic on Bluff Rd submitted by CCPO
- Exhibit J.28 Video 4.0 Large Trucks and Farm Traffic on Cottrell Rd SB at Bluff submitted by CCPO
- Exhibit J.29 Video 5.0 Character of the Area Carpenter Lane 6 September 2023 8 am submitted by CCPO
- Exhibit J.30 Video 6.0 Cottrell Rd with Truck then onto Carpenter Lane submitted by CCPO
- Exhibit J.31 Charles Waugh Explanatory Text of Videos & Testimony rec 9.6.23 (379.3 KB)
- Exhibit J.32 Suzanne Courter Rebuttal to Exhibit I.80 rec 9.6.23 (205.96 KB)
- Exhibit J.33 Suzanne Courter Rebuttal Testimony for Character of the Area and Hazardous Conditions rec 9.6.23 (671.36 KB)
- Exhibit J.34 Paul Solimano, Willamette Cultural Resource Associates response to HRA Letter dated July 24, 2023 rec 9.6.23 (188.58 KB)
- Exhibit J.35 Attorney Carrie Richter representing CCPO Response to PWB Materials submitted on or before August 7, 2023 rec 9.6.23 (14.55 MB)
- Exhibit J.36 Michael Ard, Ard Engineering Rebuttal of Exhibits I.86 and I.84 rec 9.6.23 (461.52 KB)
- Exhibit J.37 Multnomah County Rural Fire Protection District 10, Board of Directors Rebuttal Testimony in Opposition rec 9.6.23 (6.58 MB)
- Exhibit J.38 L Courter, West Slope Farms Rebuttal Testimony to Exhibit I.80 rec 9.6.23 (171.06 KB)
- Exhibit J.39 Tom Newberry Rebuttal Testimony rec 9.6.23 (11.05 MB)
- Exhibit J.40 Jim & Steve Ekstrom, Brandon Schmidt, Ekstrom & Schmidt Nursery Rebuttal Testimony to Exhibits I.83, I.80 and I.81 rec 9.6.23 (182.92 KB)
- Exhibit J.41 Andrea Culver Rebuttal Testimony to Exhibit I.80 rec 9.6.23 (205.12 KB)
- Exhibit J.42 Amalia Bruley General Rebuttal to PWB Conclusion regarding Character of the Area and Impacts to Farming Practices rec 9.6.23 (190.44 KB)
- Exhibit J.43 Shawn Nerison, Surface Nursery & Other Nurseries Rebuttal to Various PWB Exhibits rec 9.6.23 (678.63 KB)
- Exhibit J.44 Memorandum from Multnomah County Transportation to Hearings Officer regarding New Evidence Rebuttal rec 9.6.23 (297.87 KB)
- Exhibit J.45 Memorandum from Multnomah County Land Use Planning to Hearings Officer regarding Cultural Resources rec 9.6.23 (216.56 KB)
- Exhibit J.46 Residents of Carpenter Lane East of Cottrell Rebuttal Testimony in Relation to MCC 39.7515(A), (C), (D) and (E) rec 9.6.23 (275.35 KB)
- Exhibit J.47 Various Farm Equipment Photographs from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23 (198.66 KB)
- Exhibit J.48 Bicycles on Dodge Park 8-28-23 Video from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.49 Bluff Rd Hazardous Condition Video from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.51 Character of the Area Drive Typical Route 302nd to Carpenter Lane Video from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.52 Character of the Area Pedestrians on Carpenter Lane 8-30- 23 Video from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.53 Cottrell – Dangerous Alt Route Causes Delays Video from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.54 Cottrell Tractor v. Dump Truck Video from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.55 Dangerous Alt Route for Surface on Cottrell Video from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.56 Dodge Park GPS maps detour to Carpenter Lane Video from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.57 Dump Truck and Kids on Carpenter Lane Video from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.58 Equipment on Low Boy Dodge Park Video from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.59 Farm Traffic Cottrell Rd North ROW Tractor 8-28-23 Video from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.60 Farm Traffic Dodge Park Blvd 8-28-23 Video from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.61 Farm Traffic June Dodge Park Video from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.62 Impatient Car Passes Dump Trucks Cottrell and Bluff Rd rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.63 Low Volume Months Misreported by Globalwise Video from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.64 Main Site Route to Bluff Video from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.65 MCC A and E Dodge Park Cottrell Intersection Concrete Retaining Walls Proposed Video from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.66 Normal Route Carpenter to Dodge Park & Pleasant Home Video from Residents of Carpenter Lane rec 9.6.23
- Exhibit J.67 Facility Septic and Steep Slopes Supplemental Information rec 9.6.23 (257.01 KB)
- Exhibit J.68 Wolfe Lang PE GE PEng Resume (645.33 KB)
- Exhibit J.69 Facility Operational Noise Response rec 9.6.23 (371.29 KB)
- Exhibit J.70 Impacts of Lighting at Filtration Facility rec 9.6.23 (1.28 MB)
- Exhibit J.71 Odor Considerations Supplemental Information rec 9.6.23 (881.04 KB)
- Exhibit J.72 School Locations and Access Overview rec 9.6.23 (4.74 MB)
- Exhibit J.73 Outreach and Involvement with Area Schools rec 9.6.23 (275.25 KB)
- Exhibit J.74 Legislative History of Development Definition rec 9.6.23 (217.33 KB)
- Exhibit J.75 Wildlife Habitat Topics rec 9.6.23 (1.3 MB)
- Exhibit J.76 Heritage Research Associates Response to Select Testimony rec 9.6.23 (373.58 KB)
- Exhibit J.77 Dr Mengel Response to Select Testimony rec 9.6.23 (1.11 MB)
- Exhibit J.78 Dr Felsot Response to Select Testimony rec 9.6.23 (2.2 MB)
- Exhibit J.79 Performance Based Fire Protection Engineering Response to Additional Testimony rec 9.6.23 (817.18 KB)
- Exhibit J.80 Programmatic Environmental Assessment Adequacy rec 9.6.23 (290.79 KB)
- Exhibit J.81 Dust Management Supplemental Information rec 9.6.23 (2.87 MB)
- Exhibit J.82 Acoustics and Nighttime Generator Sound Levels rec 9.6.23 (982.31 KB)
- Exhibit J.83 Temporary Fire Suppression Supplemental Information rec 9.6.23 (914.18 KB)
- Exhibit J.84 Construction Compatibility with Farm Traffic Report (re-submitted) (7.3 MB)
- Exhibit J.85 Construction Transportation Demand Management Plan Update rec 9.6.23 (189.95 KB)
- Exhibit J.86 Globalwise Response to Additional Testimony rec 9.6.23 (13.72 MB)
- Exhibit J.87 Global Transportation Traffic Responses to Specific Testimony rec 9.6.23 (724.67 KB)
- Exhibit J.88 Globalwise Response to Testimony Related to Cumulative Farm Impacts (4.57 MB)
- Exhibit J.89 Truck Turning Paths at Multnomah County Intersections rec 9.6.23 (18.59 MB)
- Exhibit J.90 Carpenter Lane Trees rec 9.6.23 (305.93 KB)
- Exhibit J.91 Verification of Date & Time of PWB Submittals rec 9.6.23 (333.41 KB)
- Exhibit J.92 Cindy Bennington Rebuttal Testimony rec 9.7.23 (1.24 MB)
- Exhibit J.93 PWBPOWtrees Video from Cindy Bennington
Post Rebuttal Period
- Exhibit K.1 Extension of Final Argument Time Period (105.04 KB)
- Exhibit K.2 150-Day Time Extension (225.44 KB)
- Exhibit K.3 Hearings Officer Rappleyea Acceptance of Bennington's 9.7.23 Testimony rec 9.10.23 (78.15 KB)
Final Argument Period
- Exhibit L.1 Applicant's Final Written Argument Under ORS 197.763(6)(e) rec 9.28.23 (6.31 MB)
